MARKET UPDATE: Gaming the ERF? The role of “Bid-shading”

While the ERF was developed with the intention of purchasing abatement at ‘least cost’, in practice, businesses have a clear incentive to inflate their bids well above the cost of reducing emissions – known as “bid-shading”.

In this Market Update we examine the impact of bid-shading on ERF market dynamics, with analysis indicating that rather than bid at ‘least cost’, companies will inflate their bids towards the highest clearing price – irrespective of their project costs – with more advanced companies to optimise their expected value by accepting a lower chance of winning in return for a higher pay-off if they win.

Bid-shading will therefore create a ‘false’ auction cost curve, whereby high cost abatement may be contracted before lower cost projects, while low cost projects may be bid in at a considerable premium, disrupting the Regulator’s objective of purchasing abatement at “…the lowest price at which it is worth your while to undertake the project”.

With the majority of companies expected to inflate their bids towards the highest possible price, analysis indicates that the average price of abatement will climb toward the high end of bids, and will rapidly converge on the maximum clearing price over subsequent options.

Please login to access our full Carbon Market Update (PDF) report, titled “Gaming the ERF? The Role of Bid-Shading & Maximising Returns”, published under our Carbon Market Intelligence service.

Restricted Access

This is a subscriber report. Please login to access this content.

Not a subscriber?

To learn more about our research services for the Australian energy and emissions markets, click the button below, or email our subscriptions team.

Sign up for regular insights

LATEST UPDATES

  • ALERT: Australian CO2 spot price hits record high of $18.50/t, up 12% YTD

    Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone

    The price of Australian carbon credit units (ACCUs) reached $18.50/t on Monday, a record high, […]

    Research Insights | February 16th, 2021
  • EU levy could impose carbon price of A$65-140 on Australian exports, with more climate tariffs to come

    Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone

    The European Parliament’s environment committee last week endorsed the proposed Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), […]

    Research Insights | February 10th, 2021
  • Australian carbon offset price climbs past $17/t, a 12-month high: Here’s why

    Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone

    The price of Australian carbon offsets broke through $17 a tonne on Wednesday, reaching a […]

    Research Insights | February 4th, 2021
  • Carbon spot price climbs to 10-month high as pressure builds on government

    Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone

    The Australian carbon spot price climbed to $16.63 per tonne on Monday, a 10-month high, […]

    Research Insights | January 19th, 2021
  • Trading range narrows for Australian carbon spot price

    Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone

    The Australian carbon spot price ended the 2020 calendar year down 4.5 per cent year-on-year, […]

    Research Insights | January 13th, 2021
  • Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someone